Guest Column

Omphemetse Sibanda | GBV victims constantly failed by the system

Listen to this article
-00:00
Subscribers can listen to this article
Thousands of children are sexually exploited in Tanzania.
Thousands of children are sexually exploited in Tanzania. (Catherine Falls Commercial, Getty Images)

The recent crime statistics painted a bleak picture for gender-based violence victims, revealing that they are often failed by the criminal justice system, writes Omphemetse Sibanda.

The fourth quarter crime statistics from 1 January to the end of March 2022, released on Friday by Police Minister Bheki Cele, paint "a bleak picture of the last three months" and a violent brutal start to 2022.

As with previous reports, the prevalence of and increase in violence against women and children was to be expected.

"Murder, attempted murder, and assault GBH of women all recorded double-digit increases. Murder and assault GBH of children under the age of 17 also recorded sharp increases," said Cele.

We should not be surprised by these alarming statistics, considering we live in a country regarded as the rape capital of the world. To be specific, there were about 6 083 murders, 10 818 rapes, and 40 960 residential burglaries in just three months.

Little done

The brutal killing of women such as Tshegofatso Pule and Naledi Phangindawo remain markers for the abhorrent manner in which women are treated in South Africa. Who can forget the slaying of Nosipho Mandleleni, who Judge Mohamed Ismail described her beating as like that of "a master would a slave." African National Congress Youth League regional leader Patrick Wisani was sentenced to a mere 20 years in prison for her death.

What is nauseating is the always after-the-fact knee-jerk reaction to gender-based violence (GBV) as if our radio, print and electronic media are not reporting these daily.

As a country, we have seen a great deal of public discourse and intellectual energy misspent on discussing GBV and doing little about it.

President Cyril Ramaphosa during his address at the ANC Limpopo conference over the weekend highlighted the need to continue the fight against GBV, which he describes as a heinous crime. While the president characterises GBV as the second pandemic, the country's response to GBV is not what it should be if it were dealing with a pandemic. Some important promises have not been kept.

It's been three and a half years since the Gender-Based Violence Summit, and still there is no GBV and Femicide Council Bill as promised. History is repeating itself as happened in 2012 when the establishment of the National Council on GBV collapsed because of several factors, including lack of resources, and lack of political support from the government. The latest promise is that GBV and Femicide Council Bill will be introduced in Parliament in July.

Our criminal justice system continues to fail victims of GBV.

One hopes that our government and the criminal justice system - in particular, law enforcement - would be more concerned with the pursuit of ending human rights violations experienced by victims of GBV in the same manner we have seen resources spent on dealing with state capture. Thus far, in case you have not noticed, stories about corruption and kleptocracy continue to dwarf other issues of national interest such as GBV.

Judiciary doing its best

The Judiciary appears to be trying its best to combat GBV, particularly against women and girls.

It is the Judiciary that continues to ensure that victims of GBV are treated with dignity and not subjected to secondary victimisation by the criminal justice system. A typical example is the recent judgment of the Constitutional Court in the case of AK v Minister of Police [2022] ZACC 14, which held the Minister of Police liable to pay damages for sloppy police work relating to a case involving activist and author Andy Kawa who was held hostage and repeatedly raped over a 15-hour period in 2010.

What was most shocking though was the argument by the Police Minister that such an order of liability would "open the floodgates" for similar claims against the police. But thanks to Tleletsi AJ, who dismissed this archaic "floodgates argument" by stating that, "The state has a duty to protect women against all forms of gender-based violence that impair their enjoyment of fundamental rights and freedoms".

The Minister, citing two English cases, had argued that the Court "finding in favour of the applicant in these circumstances would have a chilling effect on its ability to conduct investigations and carry out its constitutional mandate."

To confirm just how sloppy the fact-finding and investigation culture is in the police service, the minister relied on English cases that have been discredited by the English Supreme Court itself as not aligned with the European human rights law the better.

In squashing the "chilling effect" narrative, Tlaletsi AJ held that "the state has a positive obligation to respect, protect, promote and fulfill the rights in the Bill of Rights. As such, the imposition of liability could rather be seen as accountability enhancing measure."

It was rather embarrassing that our law enforcement doesn't appear to be concerned with the horrible criminality that the victim was exposed to and instead focused on protecting the failing policing system.

The question is often asked: What can be done to better combat GBV? The answer lies in what strategy is in place.

Such strategy should have the following as its central pillars:

  • Enact a law that imposes strict and personal liability on police officers in both their professional and personal capacity for sloppy police work.
  • Such a sloppy investigation and processing of the crime scene must be considered prima facie evidence to hold the involved police officers accountable for misconduct;
  • Develop a context, evidence, and practice-informed GBV eradication strategy. The pillars of such a strategy should include, among others, the identification and eradication of drivers of GBV, including socio-economic factors;
  • Commitment towards implementation - backed by the government and political leadership commitment, accountability, and resource prioritisation;
  • Giving the structure such as the Multi-Party Women's Caucus the responsibility to monitor and evaluate the implementation of all interventions to combat GBV alongside the Commission for Gender Equality and relevant non-governmental interest groups. The strengthening of legislation on its own is not enough to bring down the levels of GBV in the country.

- Professor Dr Omphemetse S Sibanda, Legal Scholar Without Borders, is a Professor of Law and the Executive Dean of the Faculty of Management and Law at the University of Limpopo.

To receive Opinions Weekly, sign up for the newsletter here.

*Want to respond to the columnist? Send your letter or article to opinions@news24.comwith your name and town or province. You are welcome to also send a profile picture. We encourage a diversity of voices and views in our readers' submissions and reserve the right not to publish any and all submissions received.

Disclaimer: News24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24.

Omphemetse Sibanda