If a State of Disaster is used by President Cyril Ramaphosa - along with a new Minister within the ambit of his own Office - to circumvent the worst of ANC's self-induced shackles, it may be an experiment worth withstanding. But equally, its failure could result in a real disaster, writes Daniel Silke.
President Cyril Ramaphosa's seventh State of the Nation (SONA) address should really be seen in the context of the previous seven years' worth of similar showpiece events.
It's not that the content was bad or even erroneous, it's simply that the hope that the President has been peddling for the last 2500 days barely translates into tangible action. For that reason, it's relatively easy to be sceptical and cynical about SONA 2023.
South Africa's declining economic fortunes - as expressed in statistical data from its very own Stats SA and SARB - point to seven years of inertia at best and failure at worst.
Ultimately though, the dismal context has been brewing for a much longer period and is predicated not only on the somewhat vague structural issues within our society but clearly within the policy framework dictated to by the ideology of the ANC as the party of liberation.
Ideology gets in way of growth
On various critical issues facing the country, ideology gets in the way of growth. Cadre deployment - not that unique for any country - has been disastrously applied. Comrades with connections have been prioritised over comrades with skills.
But the damaging aspects have further set back the President's own desire for a 'national compact' with a group of South Africans feeling distinctly excluded from participating and contributing.
In this way, ideology stymies the advancement of the collective good and alienates skills leading to their externalisation through emigration. A shrinking tax base is but one direct consequence alongside the exit of skills from the State due to ideological 'transformation'.
To this end, one could add the decline in basic literacy affecting millions of future job seekers, a state sector barely functional, particularly in the area of transport and logistics and, of course, the collapse of the national energy grid.
For the ANC, the two key pillars of their National Democratic Revolution have largely failed - transformation through misapplied cadre deployment coupled with the related failure of the desire to achieve an efficient developmental state. State capture itself played into these ideological pillars in a particularly insidious and destructive manner.
READ | Ebrahim Harvey: Ramaphosa delivers same old lies at ANC policy conference about moribund NDR
Furthermore, since efficient local government is often a driver of prosperity, the administrative and skills-based failures in this all-important third tier of governance provide a depressing backdrop to the current malaise.
For the private sector, keen to participate in its patriotic and profit-driven duty, many of these background issues have limited their enthusiastic participation in an economy that still offers tremendous investment opportunities.
Further limiting their ability to participate adequately has been the deep-rooted ideological suspicion for the free market from the governing party. Unless reversed - even in part - that will continue to stymie the real public-private cooperation so desperately needed.
The context, therefore - for SONA 2023 - was the worst it has been since 1994. And similarly, for the ANC as a political party, its own future in power is now no longer guaranteed.
Concentration on Eskom
Given the double-whammy of a growth rate now well below 1% for this year and an ANC struggling to poll more than 40% currently, the President's address should be viewed against the critical question of whether it can contribute to an improvement of both fortunes - that of the country and that of the ANC as a political party itself.
Clearly, the President's concentration on the ongoing energy (Eskom) crisis was essential.
The impact of declaring a State of Disaster should, perhaps, not be pre-judged. While observers are right to point to its potentially flawed legal base, the propensity for financial malfeasance as emergency funding is unlocked, and the additional layer of political control that such a declaration brings, it may rather be an exercise to judge over the fullness of time.
READ | OPINION: The Disaster Management Act is not a panacea for all governance failures in SA
While never admitted by government, this declaration really amplifies the inability of the current bureaucracy to manage and repair the crisis at hand. It is an implicit admission of failure that existing departments of state and key personalities - even within the Executive - can no longer be counted on to manage the crisis. To this end, the announcement of a new ‘Minister of Electricity in the office of the Presidency' is a case in point.
While the President referred to the energy crisis as an 'existential threat' to the country's economy and social fabric, it is also an existential threat to an embattled ANC.
Politically, the ANC barely has a year to show real signs of progress and reduce the burden of blackouts. Nothing applies the mind more to a political party's actions than the fear of losing power at the polls. Indeed, if there is any real impetus to alleviate the collective suffering of all South Africans, it's the political threat of losing an overall majority that can drive change.
That the economic well-being of the country and the energy crisis are now both concurrent and symbiotic crises for the governing party, the ANC may well have just woken up to smell the proverbial roses.
Populism over pragmatism
To that end, a State of Disaster can bypass some of the structural, policy and more importantly, ideological bottlenecks that choke the domestic economy. By integrating more with the private sector and reducing the role of the reliance on Eskom itself, the ANC can use the legal framework created to shift its own internal thinking - at least when dealing with this matter.
But for South Africa to rebound in the future, the severe limitations and damage caused by the ANC's own policies and ideology need to be reversed or at least tweaked on a host of public policy and infrastructural/state sector avenues. Indeed, progress in integrating the private sector into the beleaguered Transnet is a welcome shift, and this model needs further and rapid expansion to other sectors.
The country needs much more than just a state of disaster on energy. It needs a review of other potentially damaging policies that undermine economic growth and investment.
READ | Ebrahim Harvey: Ramaphosa delivers same old lies at ANC policy conference about moribund NDR
The list can include a review of restrictive Labour policies, a shift to a much greater devolution of power to Provinces and capable Metro's to manage their own transport, energy and security services and a push-back against the notion of the nationalization of the Reserve Bank which is potentially a sentiment-damaging issue.
Finally, the political theatrics of a disruptive EFF also will impact the ANC in deciding which type of coalition partner it might need as it navigates a less secure future. Choosing populism over pragmatism (as is beginning to take shape in the City of Johannesburg and Tshwane et al) will likely set the country back to a place it may struggle to recover from.
For the ANC, choosing its future coalition partners may just be the most important choice (and potentially divisive) it will ever have to make.
The complexity of SONA 2023 this year is, therefore, a potential turning point for the ANC both in terms of its broad philosophy and political relationships.
If a State of Disaster is used by the President - along with a new Minister within the ambit of his own Office - to circumvent the worst of ANC's self-induced shackles, it may be an experiment worth withstanding. But equally, its failure will result in a real disaster, not just for energy this time, but for the entire 60 million population in every city, town or village and in every walk of life.
- Daniel Silke is the director of Political Futures Consulting.
*Want to respond to the columnist? Send your letter or article to opinions@news24.comwith your name and town or province. You are welcome to also send a profile picture. We encourage a diversity of voices and views in our readers' submissions and reserve the right not to publish any and all submissions received.
Disclaimer: News24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of columnists published on News24 are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of News24.























